Mystery #37

For most of human history I did not exist, and arithmetic managed without me.

The first of five clues. Each one below gives a little more away.

1

For most of human history I did not exist, and arithmetic managed without me.

2

Rome built an empire without me, and could not have written the year 2000.

3

India gave me a name and a set of rules, and the idea travelled west through Baghdad.

4

Divide by me and mathematics refuses to answer.

5

The digit that means nothing and changes everything.

The answer

Zero

Brahmagupta set out the rules for it in 628 AD, including — correctly — that division by it has no answer. Europe resisted the whole idea for another five hundred years.

Babylonians used a placeholder mark, but a placeholder is not a number. The step that mattered was treating nothing as a quantity you can add, subtract and reason about, and that appears in Brahmagupta's Brahmasphutasiddhanta in 628 AD, complete with the rules — including that division by it yields no answer. The idea travelled through Baghdad into al-Khwarizmi's arithmetic and reached Europe with Fibonacci in 1202, where several Italian cities banned the new numerals as a fraud risk, since an unscrupulous clerk could turn a nought into a six far more easily than he could alter XVIII.

Play it properly

Reading five clues at once is not the game. In the real thing they arrive one at a time and every wrong guess costs an hour. Play mystery #37 · today's mystery · the vault

Nearby mysteries

Previous: mystery #36. Next: mystery #38. Or try #45, #46, #47, #48, #49, #50.